Skip to content 
Sending an annual appeal is one of the most crucial fundraising initiatives for nonprofits. It’s an opportunity to share your successes, highlight the importance of donor support, and make a compelling case for further contributions.
This blog will guide you through best practices, strategies, and annual appeal letter examples to help your nonprofit maximize its fundraising efforts. We’ll explore the following:
Understanding the Importance of Annual Appeals
An annual appeal is a vital tool for nonprofits. It helps to secure the necessary funds to cover operational costs, support ongoing programs, and fund new initiatives.
Unlike project-specific fundraising campaigns, an annual appeal focuses on the broader needs of the organization, ensuring its sustainability and growth.
Why Annual Appeals Matter
- Sustained Support: Annual appeals help maintain a steady stream of donations throughout the year, ensuring that your nonprofit can meet its financial obligations.
- Donor Retention: Regular communication through annual appeals helps to build and maintain relationships with donors, increasing donor retention rates.
- Fundraising Efficiency: By consolidating your fundraising efforts into a well-planned annual appeal, you can streamline your processes and reduce the time and resources spent on multiple smaller campaigns.
Crafting the Perfect Annual Appeal Letter
Writing an effective annual appeal letter is both an art and a science. It requires a deep understanding of your audience, a compelling narrative, and a clear call to action.
Here are some best practices to help you create an engaging and successful annual appeal letter.
Best Practices for Writing an Annual Appeal Letter
- Make It Personal: Address your donors by name and use a conversational tone. Personalization makes donors feel valued and appreciated.
- Tell a Story: Use storytelling to connect with your donors on an emotional level. Share a story about a beneficiary who has been positively impacted by your organization’s work.
- Be Clear and Concise: Avoid jargon and keep your letter straightforward. Use short paragraphs and bullet points to make it easy to read.
- Focus on the Donor: Use second-person pronouns like “you” and “your” more often than first-person pronouns like “I” and “we.” Highlight how the donor’s contributions have made a difference.
- Include a Strong Call to Action: Clearly state what you want the donor to do. Make your ask specific and urgent, such as “Donate now to provide shelter to 30 families in need.”
- Provide Multiple Ways to Donate: Offer various donation methods, such as online, by mail, or through social media. Make sure your donation form follows best practices, like those offered by Sumac donor management software, to make it convenient for donors to contribute.
How To Write An Annual Appeal: Best Practices & Examples
Annual Appeal Letter Examples
Here are examples of different types of annual appeal letters written by nonprofit organizations.
#1 Direct Mail Annual Appeal Letter Example
This annual appeal for Emmanuel College is a great example of how to appeal to the specific interests of donors. It’s been sent to past alumni of the college and emphasizes this connection – speaking about the value the college delivered to past students and urging them to contribute to help the college continue to deliver an excellent education to students.
The annual appeal includes images of the students to give a face to the story and engages readers. Finally, it also includes an easy way for alumni to donate by including a slip that they can mail back with convenient checkboxes with suggested donation amounts.
Make sure that your annual appeal letters are easy to read, include images and speak to the needs of potential donors so they feel emotionally connected to your cause – just like this letter from Emmanuel College.
#2 Email Annual Appeal Example
This email appeal by BirdsCaribbean, asked readers to support with a year-end donation and followed their appeal with a detailed bullet point list that explained how the money would be used, including expanding their projects, maintaining current programs, providing training to volunteers and paying staff.
It includes a clear goal that donors can help contribute towards and then breaks up where the money will go. The email doesn’t waste time getting to the point – readers are aware of the ask and how to donate in the first paragraph – this is especially important for email campaigns as most people only read the first few lines of an email before closing it.
Once they have grabbed attention the email continues with details about how the donations will be used and emphasizes that all gifts are tax-deductible. The photos used are also to elicit some emotional connection with an audience who cares about birds.
.png)
When writing your appeal emails, make sure they are short, get to the point quickly and include a clear call-to-action – preferably with a button – where readers can easily donate to your cause.
#3 Peer-to-peer Annual Appeal (Website) Example
If you have a lot of supporters from your existing donor base that are very engaged with your organization – consider asking them to get more involved in your cause with peer-to-peer fundraising. Here is an example of how Macey Mayhugh created a fundraising page for Embraced International’s annual appeal campaign.
Your volunteers or past donors can create their own pages and use their networks to fundraise for your cause. You may want to provide them with certain materials and give them accurate information about how you will use the funds raised.
One of the biggest reasons people give is hearing good things about an organization from their peers. This appeal highlights why Macey thinks they are a great organization and what compels her to donate to them. It then includes information about Embraced International’s campaigns and what they do.
.png)
Peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns are a great way to not only raise money – but also bring in new donors and raise awareness about your organization amongst people you may not have reached in the past. If you plan to create a campaign like this one, make sure you approve the pages before they are published to ensure everything is accurate.
Annual Appeal Letter Templates
Here are a few annual appeal letter examples to inspire your own (you can also try our AI Donation Request Letter Generator powered by ChatGPT to create your own):
Template 1: Personal and Emotional
Dear [Donor’s Name],
I hope this letter finds you well. As we reflect on the past year, we are filled with gratitude for your unwavering support. Thanks to your generosity, we were able to provide shelter, food, and education to over 500 children in need.
One of these children is Sarah, a bright and determined young girl who dreams of becoming a doctor. With your help, Sarah now has a safe place to live and access to quality education. Her story is a testament to the incredible impact of your contributions.
As we look ahead, we are excited to continue our mission of transforming lives. But we can’t do it without you. Your donation today will ensure that more children like Sarah have the opportunity to thrive.
Please consider making a gift of $50, $100, or whatever you can afford. Every dollar counts and makes a difference.
Thank you for your continued support.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Your Title]
[Your Nonprofit]
Template 2: Data-Driven and Urgent
Dear [Donor’s Name],
Did you know that 1 in 5 children in our community goes to bed hungry every night? It’s a heartbreaking statistic, but with your help, we can change it.
Last year, your generous donations allowed us to provide over 10,000 meals to children in need. But the need is still great, and we urgently need your support to continue this vital work.
Please make a donation today to help us reach our goal of providing 15,000 meals by the end of the year. Your gift of $25, $50, or $100 will make a significant impact.
Together, we can ensure that no child goes to bed hungry.
Thank you for your compassion and generosity.
Warm regards,
[Your Name]
[Your Title]
[Your Nonprofit]
More letter writing resources:
- Get more letter writing tips & examples: Check out How to write the perfect fundraising letter.
- Partner with expert fundraising letter writers to ensure success: Hire Frontier nonprofit marketing agency.
Strategies for a Successful Annual Appeal
In addition to writing a compelling annual appeal letter, there are several strategies you can employ to maximize your fundraising efforts.
1. Segment Your Donor List
Not all donors are the same, and your appeal should reflect that. Segment your donor list based on factors such as donation history, engagement level, and interests. Tailor your messaging to each segment to make your appeal more relevant and compelling.
2. Use Multi-Channel Marketing
Don’t rely solely on direct mail for your annual appeal. Use a combination of channels, including email, social media, and your website, to reach a broader audience. Consistent messaging across all channels reinforces your appeal and increases the likelihood of donations.
3. Leverage Matching Gifts
Encourage donors to take advantage of matching gift programs offered by their employers. Highlight the impact of matching gifts in your appeal and provide information on how donors can participate.
4. Showcase Impact
Use visuals, such as photos and videos, to show the impact of your work. Share success stories and testimonials from beneficiaries to illustrate how donations are making a difference.
5. Follow Up
Don’t forget to follow up with donors after they’ve made a contribution. Send a personalized thank-you note and update them on the progress of your campaign. Continued communication helps to build stronger relationships and encourages future donations.
6. Utilize Technology
Consider using nonprofit CRM and donor management software like Sumac CRM to streamline your fundraising efforts. These tools can help you track donor interactions, segment your donor list, and automate follow-up communications.
Additional Tips for a Strong Annual Appeal
Plan Your Campaign Schedule
It’s important to plan your campaign schedule in advance. Determine the best time to send your annual appeal letter and coordinate your efforts across all channels. This will help you prioritize the creation of your appeals and marketing collateral, saving you time when you launch your campaign.
Build Your Marketing Collateral
Create all your marketing collateral in advance, including your direct mail letter, email appeals, social media posts, and paid advertisements. Promote your campaign on your website through a homepage banner, blog post, and giving page updates.
By creating everything in advance, you’ll save time and headaches during the campaign itself. Consider partnering with a charity marketing agency for help.
Provide a Clear Call to Action
Your call to action should be clear and specific. Tell your donors exactly what you want them to do and why it’s important. For example, instead of saying “Donate now,” say “Donate now to provide shelter to 30 families in need.” Including a second call to action in a P.S. can capture readers who skip to the bottom of your letter.
Test and Optimize
Don’t be afraid to test different elements of your annual appeal letter, such as subject lines, messaging, and calls to action. Use A/B testing to determine what resonates best with your audience and optimize your appeal accordingly.
Conclusion
Crafting a successful annual appeal requires careful planning, compelling storytelling, and a clear call to action. By following the best practices and strategies outlined in this blog, you can create an annual appeal that resonates with your donors and drives donations to support your mission.
Remember to personalize your appeal, use storytelling to connect with your donors, and provide multiple ways to donate. Utilize technology, such as your nonprofit CRM to streamline your efforts and maximize your impact.
By taking a strategic approach to your annual appeal, you can build stronger relationships with your donors, increase donor retention rates, and secure the necessary funds to support your organization’s important work. Happy fundraising!
