Skip to content 
In the world of nonprofits, effective marketing can be the difference between thriving and merely surviving. With so many causes competing for attention and donations, it’s crucial to partner with a charity marketing agency that understands the unique challenges and opportunities within the nonprofit sector.
In Canada, several agencies stand out for their exceptional work in helping charities achieve their goals. Below, we’ll explore the top five charity marketing agencies in Canada, starting with the unparalleled Frontier Marketing. We’ll explore the following:
#1 Frontier Marketing
Frontier Marketing is a full-service charity marketing agency that has been helping nonprofits raise tens of millions over the past 12 years. Frontier’s approach is holistic, integrating direct mail fundraising, digital campaigns, and personalized consultation to create sustainable growth for their clients.
Why Frontier Marketing Stands Out
Comprehensive Services:
Frontier offers a range of services, including direct mail fundraising, digital fundraising, and personalized consulting. Their team of strategists, creatives, and data specialists craft impactful, results-driven campaigns that connect with donors on a personal level.
Proven Success:
Frontier has a track record of delivering huge results for charities, helping them raise tens of millions over the last decade.
- For instance, Frontier built a winning annual match campaign for Union Gospel Mission, raising $1,835,065—a 20% increase from previous years.
- Similarly, their direct mail acquisition campaign for ADRA Canada resulted in a 106% increase in appeal response rates and a 70% increase in the average gift size.
Read more about Frontier’s success stories in 10 Very Good Reasons to Hire a Nonprofit Marketing Agency
Personalized Consultation:
Frontier offers personalized coaching and consulting, acting as an extension of your team to help you achieve new levels of fundraising success. Their comprehensive data analysis helps identify donor trends and optimize your fundraising strategy for maximum impact.
How Frontier Can Help Your Nonprofit
Frontier’s expertise in direct mail and digital fundraising can help your nonprofit engage and convert donors more effectively. Their personalized consultation services can provide the insights and strategies needed to elevate your fundraising efforts. If you’re looking for a nonprofit marketing agency that can deliver results, Frontier is your go-to choice.
#2 Agents of Good
Agents of Good is another top-tier charity marketing agency based in Canada, known for their focus on donor-centric fundraising. Founded by John Lepp and Jen Love, this agency emphasizes the importance of showing love to donors through their innovative and heartfelt campaigns.
Why Agents of Good Stands Out
Donor-Centric Approach:
Agents of Good believe in treating donors as heroes of their own stories. They focus on creating emotional connections between donors and the causes they support, which helps in building long-term relationships.
Innovative Campaigns:
The agency is known for its creative and innovative campaigns that stand out in the crowded nonprofit sector. Their work often includes personalized direct mail, engaging storytelling, and unique fundraising events.
Expertise in Direct Mail:
Agents of Good have set the bar for quality in direct mail, print, and design. Their direct mail campaigns are not just about asking for donations but about showing gratitude and making donors feel valued.
How Agents of Good Can Help Your Nonprofit
If your nonprofit is looking to build stronger relationships with donors and create campaigns that truly resonate, Agents of Good can provide the expertise and creativity needed. Their donor-centric approach ensures that your fundraising efforts are both effective and meaningful.
3. Good Works
Good Works is a Canadian charity marketing agency that specializes in helping nonprofits build strong relationships with their donors. Founded by Leah Eustace, ACFRE, Fraser Green, and Holly Wagg, Good Works is known for its data-driven approach and innovative fundraising strategies.
Why Good Works Stands Out
Data-Driven Strategies:
Good Works uses data to inform their fundraising strategies, ensuring that every campaign is optimized for success. They conduct thorough research and analysis to understand donor behavior and preferences.
Creative Fundraising:
The agency is known for its creative approach to fundraising. They develop unique campaigns that capture donors’ attention and inspire them to take action. Whether it’s through direct mail, digital campaigns, or events, Good Works knows how to engage donors effectively.
Experienced Team:
With a team of seasoned professionals, Good Works brings a wealth of experience and expertise to every project. They have worked with a wide range of nonprofits, from small local charities to large national organizations.
How Good Works Can Help Your Nonprofit
Good Works can help your nonprofit leverage data to create targeted and effective fundraising campaigns. Their creative approach ensures that your campaigns stand out and resonate with donors. If you’re looking for a charity marketing agency that combines data-driven strategies with creative execution, Good Works is an excellent choice.
4. Blakely
Blakely is a leading charity marketing agency in Canada, known for its strategic approach to fundraising. With over 30 years of experience, Blakely has helped numerous nonprofits achieve their fundraising goals through innovative and effective campaigns.
Why Blakely Stands Out
Strategic Fundraising:
Blakely takes a strategic approach to fundraising, focusing on long-term growth and sustainability. They develop comprehensive fundraising plans that align with their clients’ goals and objectives.
Innovative Campaigns:
The agency is known for its innovative campaigns that capture donors’ attention and drive engagement. They use a mix of traditional and digital channels to reach donors and inspire them to give.
Experienced Team:
Blakely’s team of fundraising experts brings a wealth of knowledge and experience to every project. They have worked with a diverse range of nonprofits, from healthcare organizations to environmental groups.
How Blakely Can Help Your Nonprofit
Blakely can help your nonprofit develop a strategic fundraising plan that drives long-term growth. Their innovative campaigns ensure that your message stands out and resonates with donors. If you’re looking for a charity marketing agency with a strategic focus, Blakely is a great option.
5. Stephen Thomas Ltd.
Stephen Thomas Ltd. (ST) is a full-service charity marketing agency based in Toronto, Canada. With over 40 years of experience, ST has helped numerous nonprofits achieve their fundraising goals through creative and effective campaigns.
Why Stephen Thomas Ltd. Stands Out
Full-Service Agency:
ST offers a wide range of services, including direct mail, digital marketing, and fundraising consulting. Their comprehensive approach ensures that all aspects of your fundraising strategy are covered.
Creative Campaigns:
The agency is known for its creative and innovative campaigns that capture donors’ attention and inspire them to give. They use a mix of traditional and digital channels to reach donors and drive engagement.
Experienced Team:
ST’s team of fundraising experts brings a wealth of knowledge and experience to every project. They have worked with a diverse range of nonprofits, from healthcare organizations to environmental groups.
How Stephen Thomas Ltd. Can Help Your Nonprofit
ST can help your nonprofit develop a comprehensive fundraising strategy that drives engagement and donations. Their creative campaigns ensure that your message stands out and resonates with donors. If you’re looking for a full-service charity marketing agency with a proven track record, Stephen Thomas Ltd. is an excellent choice.
How Sumac Solutions Can Enhance Your Fundraising Efforts
While partnering with a top charity marketing agency is crucial, leveraging the right tools can further enhance your fundraising efforts. Sumac offers a range of solutions designed to help nonprofits manage their operations more efficiently and effectively.
Sumac CRM
A nonprofit CRM can help you manage your donor relationships more effectively. Sumac CRM offers a comprehensive solution for tracking donor interactions, managing campaigns, and analyzing donor data. By using Sumac CRM, you can gain valuable insights into donor behavior and preferences, allowing you to tailor your fundraising strategies for maximum impact.
Sumac Donations
Managing donations is a critical aspect of any nonprofit’s operations. Sumac Donations is a powerful donor management software that helps you track and manage donations, generate receipts, and analyze donation trends. With Sumac Donations, you can streamline your donation management process and ensure that every donation is accounted for.
Sumac Case Management
For nonprofits that provide services to clients, Sumac Case Management offers a comprehensive nonprofit case management software solution. This tool helps you manage client information, track service delivery, and generate reports. By using Sumac Case Management, you can ensure that your services are delivered efficiently and effectively.
Conclusion
Choosing the right charity marketing agency can significantly impact your nonprofit’s success. Frontier Marketing, Agents of Good, Good Works, Blakely, and Stephen Thomas Ltd. are among the top charity marketing agencies in Canada, each offering unique strengths and expertise.
By partnering with one of these agencies and leveraging tools like Sumac CRM, Sumac Donations, and Sumac Case Management, your nonprofit can achieve new levels of fundraising success.
Remember, effective marketing is not just about raising funds; it’s about building relationships, telling compelling stories, and inspiring people to take action. With the right agency and tools, your nonprofit can make a lasting impact and continue to do more good in the world.
